Bleecker Street Pizza New York Yelp Reviews - Bleecker Street Pizza New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Bleecker Street Pizza New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Bleecker Street Pizza New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Bleecker Street Pizza New York
Bleecker Street Pizza New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
45 Reviews
0 Replys |
I had one of the lousiest slices of pizza yesterday, April
I had one of the lousiest slices of pizza yesterday, April 24, 2024, and at $3.95+ tax is a huge ripoff! The mozzarella cheese is seriously lacking and tasting very rubbery with no oil on it! I don't know who owns it nowadays but this pizzeria needs a radical revamping of its pizza-making ... and drop its prices down to a reasonable figure ... assuming I ever return to try it again? Doug and Tony owned it years ago. Who owns it today?
Be the first to ReplyBleecker Street Pizza is the best after bar food!!! The
Bleecker Street Pizza is the best after bar food!!! The variety of pizza is amazing. I ordered the penne pizza and it was phenomenal!! So unique. The grandma square pizza were so doughy and the sauce was flavorful.
Be the first to ReplyMy favorite pizza place in New York! The restaurant is at
My favorite pizza place in New York! The restaurant is at the corner of Bleecker St. & 7th Ave. - not far from subway. There are indoor tables and some seating outside. I chose my pizza, paid & someone will call you when your order is ready. There are pictures of famous people on the wall. The pizza has a nice crispy crust. It had a dusting of cornmeal which I like because it made the pizza extra crunchy. The sauce was delicious and fresh! - Pepperoni pie: yum! They gave loads of pepperoni on top. Although the pepperoni was a bit spicy for my kid's liking, he finished the pizza! - Nonna Maria pizza: the combination of the sauce, cheese, mozzarella was perfection! The mozzarella tasted very fresh! One of the most delicious pizza I've ever had!
Be the first to ReplyNice crispy slice , quick service and cute ambiance to stop
Nice crispy slice , quick service and cute ambiance to stop by with kids. Must try when you in the area
Be the first to Replybest spot to grab pizza in the area imo- usually a long
best spot to grab pizza in the area imo- usually a long wait at night but so worth it!!
Be the first to ReplyCame here after seeing John Barr's YouTube video.
The Nonna Marie slice is amazing! The best balance between crust, sauce and cheese. Also lots of flavor. The best pizza I have very had in Manhattan.
Be the first to ReplyMy favorite pizza spot in the city.
Greg is the once owner of the fine establishment takes time to talk to guests and tell his Bleecker Street Pizza story. They've recently expanded over the years, so there is more seating. Love this spot!
Be the first to ReplyThis is, hands down, the best pizza I have ever had.
Bo frills. Just pizza. So amazingly good that it should be illegal!
Be the first to ReplyThis place is awesome.
Definitely coming back. Crust is great, the Nona is damn good.
Be the first to ReplySo we were only in town for a few days and with a list of
So we were only in town for a few days and with a list of places to eat that was longer than the amount of time and stomach space we had possession of we had to make some tough decisions. We all had a major NY style pizza craving but we could only allot one meal/snack for it. In order to not take any chances we went straight to Bleecker Street to stuff our faces with slices of the glorious Nonna Maria. The crust was so crisp on the bottom with a physics defying thin layer of fluffy airy crust on top. The magic are the bread crumbs that they add to the dough. And of course their Nonna Maria toppings of mozzarella, basil, and that homemade tangy sweet marinara sauce are the perfect crown for that royal crust. No matter how many places try and make this pizza it seemingly cannot be duplicated. It must be the tap water that comes straight from that corner of Bleecker Street. Wish I could live next door!
Be the first to ReplySolid pizza place with no line when we arrived and a large
Solid pizza place with no line when we arrived and a large indoor seating. An excellent choice if you're in the mood for a friendly staff and very fast pizza turnaround!
Be the first to ReplyFinally got to try this famous pizzeria! I can see why it's
Finally got to try this famous pizzeria! I can see why it's so famous, there was a lot of people and not much room to walk or sit. Thankfully I already knew what I was ordering and found room to sit outside. The service was on point! The guys were quick & didn't make my food hot which was great because Iam not a fan of burning my mouth! LolI loved the pizza!!! My favorite slice will always be pepperoni but i of course had to get their Nonna Maria and wow!! It didn't disappoint! I held back and only got two slices! Next time i will definitely try more food!
Be the first to ReplyExcellent pizza, great service.
The gluten free pizza was incredible. And Greg at Bleecker Street Pizza is so kind! He greeted us and made us feel like family. We are visitors and will be coming back here every time we visit New York City.
Be the first to ReplyI love Bleecker Street.
Living nearby, they are my go-to pizza place - the secret is in the sauce. I received the same quality today, but the presentation was awful!! Please see the photo - You guys can do better. Also I would appreciate more than one grape leaf in my greek salad.
Be the first to ReplyPizza was great, but they ran out of a lot of types.
Was by at about 8:30 on a Saturday night and it was packed. They were out of grandma, white, buffalo, and a few more. Grabbed a Nonna (delicious), pepperoni (greasy but good), and cheese (someone else's slice). Managed to grab a table and scrunch in. A bit loud for my personal taste, but the atmosphere was great and everyone in the place was enjoying it.
Be the first to ReplyFirst, the pizza was delicious.
We went on a 4 day pizza pilgrimage to NYC, tasting as many iconic/highly rated places that we could get to. Bleeker Street Pizza was very good and held its own with the other top places. The pizza was crisp, well balanced (dough, sauce, cheese) and proportioned well. Fresh tomato sauce, tasty cheese, and the Nonna Maria slice was one of the best slices I have ever had. The shop was clean and we were greeted by the late founder's brother, Greg, who made us feel like family. My wife and I would highly recommend this pizza.
Be the first to ReplyThe pizza was obviously a pie that had been cooked and left
The pizza was obviously a pie that had been cooked and left out. My topping was added and re-cooked. The bottom was burned and charred, the top did not move, the pie was stiff as a board and would not bend. The dollar pizza is a better quality. The pie I ordered before this one arrived on it's side. The crust was bare everything else a blob on the side.I used to love this place but it's changed for the worse.
Be the first to ReplyLove this place It's one of my favorite places for pizzaIn
Love this place It's one of my favorite places for pizzaIn Manhattan. BUT I was just there again last week and they shorted my change again for the 3rd time in a row. I noted this same issue with the customer after me. Seems they don't like to handle small change. When I questioned them the looked surprised and irritated that I wanted correct change. I told them I work for my money. COUNT YOUR CHANGE
Be the first to ReplyAmazing pizza! Two slices for $10 including tip.
No wait on a Saturday night. Both the cheese pizza and the veggie slice were amazing.
Be the first to ReplyI've been following NY YouTuber John Barr for
I've been following NY YouTuber John Barr for recommendations and tips. He has this listed as his fav slice in the city and I understand why!The restaurant is actually bigger and cleaner then most casual pizza spots you'll find in Chelsea / Grenwhich Village. Lady at the counter was great and every working there makes sure your taken care ofThe actual slice was good but sauce is the standout for sure! It has the perfect balance of acidity from the fresh tomatoes but still some of those fresh seasonings and herbs you wanna taste in there. Cheese was of a high quality but it was such a thick layer that it was still kind of congealed so each chew felt like I'd finish the the bottom layer quick and still have to chew twice as long to finish the cheese. I'd recommend asking them to keep it in the over a minute longer so it can melt down.However..... what makes this a 4 and not a 3 is the GRANDMA SLICE! It's no picture because I ate it so damn fast! That was great! Same perfect tomato sauce but less cheese so it all flowed together a lot better. The damn crust on this slice was perfect and tasted different from the Nona Maria slice crust.
Be the first to ReplyVery an assuming place, but the pizza is one of the best in
Very an assuming place, but the pizza is one of the best in NYC. Worth the trip to Greenwich village.
Be the first to ReplyIf you want to come to NY and grab a good slice, I'd
If you want to come to NY and grab a good slice, I'd definitely recommend coming here. Me and a group of friends came here on a food tour since it was one of the stops. We met with Greg, who gave us the background of the restaurant and some other interesting information. After a little more conversation, we dug into our slices and happily enjoyed them. I'd say it's defined some of the best pizza I've had from around here, and others in my group agreed. I'll be back next time I'm in the area.
Be the first to ReplyThis was the best casual pizza we had on this trip! So much
This was the best casual pizza we had on this trip! So much so that we came here twice! Overall, we had the Nonna Maria, Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni, White, Mushroom, Sicilian. All were very good, with the crust and bottom nice and crispy but not too much. They were fair with the toppings, given each slice is $4-6. The slices were really good fresh, only ok and too greasy when taken to-go. Definitely recommend eating this hot and fresh out of the oven!
Be the first to ReplyBest pizza ever.
Greg was super friendly and welcoming and the food was outstanding. Can't wait to come back
Be the first to ReplyJust tried the margarita pizza and white pizza and LOVED
Just tried the margarita pizza and white pizza and LOVED LOVED LOVED them! Crust was perfect, tasty & crispy. We met Greg, charming warm guy who made us feel welcome and gave some slices on the house to celebrate my daughter's graduation. Wonderful and wanna bring some home.
Be the first to Reply