Getting a Reservation at Carmine's New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Carmine's New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Carmine's New York Reviews from The Last Year
Food was absolutely delicious! They had a special night
Food was absolutely delicious! They had a special night with spaghetti carbonara and it was amazing. We also ordered the lasagna which did not disappoint. There was plenty of food to feed a party of six.
So came in before a Broadway show.
We sat at the bar. The bar tender was very polite and attentive. It was a little annoying though because the dishes are so large when people can to sit down to wait for their table it felt like they were breathing over our food. This is FAMILY STYLE! The servings were very large the pasta could serve two big eateries or four regular eaters. We got the penne Al a vodka which is the vegetarian style !! We also got the shrimp scampi. Which came with 11 jumbo shrimps. Got a basket of bread (cold ) that was disappointing. All in all it was a good spot. Not cheap be prepared to spend it cost almost 100 for those two dishes no drinks or dessert.
I'm extremely disappointed from my last experience.
The restaurant is understaffed with waiters running around and cleaning their own tables instead of paying attention to the guests. I was also surprised to learn that they make their pasta dishes with canola oil. Canola! Clearly the owners are trying to save some money. That explains the low quality wines with unreasonable prices and the waiters desperately trying to "sell" you another dish. Extremely poor management running a "fake it till you make it" tourist trap!
Rude Waiter by the name of Jonathan.
So I paid for my food which came to $205. I paid in cash. I didnt put my waiter Jonathans $40 tip with the $205 because I was going to leave it on the table. So my waiter Jonathan noticed the tip wasnt with the $205 for my food and he came back to my table very nasty asking for his tip. He storms back and hes like "SO WHERES MY TIP?!" I was shocked! So I hand him his $40 tip that I was going to leave on the table. He was very rude and nasty about it. He was talking so loud that people were looking at us. Thats unacceptable. At that point I didnt want to leave a tip at all. Jonathan needs to work on his attitude.
So I paid for my food which came to $205.
I paid in cash. I didnt put my waiter Jonathans $40 tip with the $205 because I was going to leave it on the table. So my waiter Jonathan noticed the tip wasnt with the $205 for my food and he came back to my table very nasty asking for his tip. He storms back and hes like "SO WHERES MY TIP?!" I was shocked! So I hand him his $40 tip that I was going to leave on the table. He was very rude and nasty about it. He was talking so loud that people were looking at us. Thats unacceptable. At that point I didnt want to leave a tip at all. Jonathan needs to work on his rude attitude.
What a disappointment for my birthday.
.... the service was VERY slow, and we were severely neglected. No one asked if we needed more drinks, when I said I needed Parmesan cheese I was given a cheese shaker with a tiny amount of cheese crusted into the bottom of the jar. Clearly there was nothing left in this cheese shaker. Took 30 min to get our check. We had to repeat things so many times. We ordered the steak, it wasn't communicated that it was $155 lol. But the worst part, as I sat there excited for my birthday, listening to other tables get sang happy birthday.. no one ever made it to me. We were handed the check for almost $400 for 3 dishes.. and not ANYTHING for my birthday. Not a cookie. Not a song. Nothing!!! And they knew it was my birthday the host verified with me that I was celebrating my birthday. It was the biggest disappointment.
Showed up 45 minutes earlier then my 8:30PM Open Table
Showed up 45 minutes earlier then my 8:30PM Open Table reservation for two and checked in with the hostess hoping to be seated earlier if possible. Was directed to wait at the bar where I purchased 3 drinks while waiting. Upon being called at 8:30PM I was taken to a rather undesirable table of which I declined as a major part of the appeal to this restaurant is it's ambiance. Eventually seated 25 inured after our initial scheduled reservation and having waited in restaurant for 45 minutes finally seated a better table but still against a wall and not near the heart of the restaurant. All this edit only to find that the entree me snd my son wanted to order, the 2 pound lobster organnata was not a available. Suffice it to say I'm highly disappointed in this place. Dinner dishes are family style so it was to feed both my son and I, do in the end Teo dinners didn't get what they had hoped for, I've ordered a different entree but I'll conclude my review with a caution in dining in this restaurant. Very disappointed, I'd it were t so late we'd eat elsewhere.
We go here every time we visit NYC.
The food is the best!!! It is not really a place for 2-best to have 3-4 people. The staff are great and we love the ravioli and Caesar salad!!
Talk about a theater weekend! I saw five Broadway shows in
Talk about a theater weekend! I saw five Broadway shows in 4 days. I also got to visit the new Museum of Broadway which was very interesting and lots of fun! One of my former students, Avilon Tate, was starring in The Wiz on Broadway, and I just had to be in the audience! What a treat to be sitting in the seventh row with his mom, grandmother, Aunt and friends. A night I'll never forget! What made this trip even more special was my visit to Carmine's before one of the shows. Oh my God. I don't even know where to begin... I had been to Carmine's years ago with Amy and her family. I had forgotten about the family style servings but I did remember the meal was bountiful and scrumptious. Even though I was by myself, I wanted to revisit that incredible experience and have dinner at their 44th Street location in the heart of Broadway. I was able to make a reservation online for 5pm but since I'm only one person they would only let me make a reservation at the bar. I was not thrilled about that, but when I arrived I was pleasantly surprised to see that my bar seat was a very comfortable high back chair and table alongside the bar. I had a bird's eye view of the expansiveness of this restaurant and enjoyed being perched up there awaiting my Italian feast! My waiter was charming and when I told him I had to have my favorite, chicken parmesan, he did remind me that it is a large portion a la family style and that it did not come with pasta. I could not imagine enjoying chicken parmesan without my spaghetti so I added that to the order. He said with a grin on his face, "I hope you have a big appetite!" I enjoyed a big basket of a variety of Italian breads. Everything warm and delicious! and my diet Coke refills kept coming as I took in dozens and dozens of happy families and friends enjoying this their meal in this landmark restaurant. When my platter arrived I almost fell off my high back chair. The thing was freaking humongous. How in the world was I ever going to make a dent in this? As much as I love chicken parmesan... The waiter could see I was freaked out and reminded me that I could always get a doggy bag. The problem was, I was heading to the theater after dinner and did not have a fridge back at my hotel. In the meantime, I decided to dig in and do as much damage as I could. Oh my God it was absolutely delicious! So much spaghetti and so much chicken parmesan and so much Italian bread and so much diet Coke. Everything I love. Besides, I was in New York and about to see a Broadway show! I got through about half and could not take one more bite. My charming waiter wrapped everything up for me in a doggy bag. On the way to the theater I saw a homeless hungry man sitting in the street and so I walked up to him and offered him a delicious Italian meal. He turned me down, telling me he was waiting on a friend to get him a hamburger at McDonald's. What else can I say? I could not part with that meal and stuck it in a bag in my sport jacket and brought it into the theater with me. LOL No, I did NOT eat it during the show!!!! That night when I got home to my hotel, I worked on it a little more and with a broken heart I threw the rest of it out. Needless to say, I loved the meal, I loved the atmosphere, I love the portion. I loved the waiter and loved the experience. I was pleasantly surprised that although it was priced a bit on the high side, it really was not a big price when you saw the portion and quality and service of what you received. I thought everything was wonderful. They are doing all of the right things. So next time you are going to see a Hit on Broadway, I suggest you go to Carmine's for dinner which in my opinion is a huge hit as well and also deserves a standing ovation! Enjoy!!
What an Italian restaurant should be about
Eating in New York City is all about New York-style pizza, New York cheesecake, Manhattan clam chowder, pastrami on rye, bagels with lox and cream cheese, chicken and waffles and soft pretzels with mustard or cheese dip. And Italian restaurants. Like Carmine's, which opened in 1992 at 200 West 44th Street in Times Square, at Shubert Aly and 8th Avenue, in Midtown Manhattan's Theatre District. Open from 11:30 to 11 Sunday, Monday and Tuesday and 11:30 to midnight from Wednesday through Saturday, this place reminds diners that red sauce, garlic and good times will never go out of style. Carmine's specializes in southern Italian cooking, features a full bar and recommends stuffed mushrooms, ravioli and shrimp scampi. The main dining room has beige walls, wood paneling and antique-style brass chandeliers. A blood-red leather banquette and large tables accommodate large, rollicking parties. Numerous black-and-white photographs of famous Italian-Americans are joined by larger-than-life paintings of Fiorello La Guardia, Enrico Caruso and Jimmy Durante. My wife and I started with garlic bread, Caesar salad, shrimp cocktail and Zuppe de Mussels. For her entree, my wife chose lasagna with beef, ricotta and marinara sauce with sauteed spinach. I opted for veal scaloppine with lemon/butter, meatballs and sauteed broccoli. For dessert, we shared bread pudding and strawberry shortcake. Carmine's is too good to host only one location. Others are at 2450 Broadway on the Upper West Side and 358 Graham Avenue in Brooklyn.
Had a reservation at 5:15 and was seated within 5 minutes
Had a reservation at 5:15 and was seated within 5 minutes of our intended reservation. Place was packed. It took quite a while before anyone addressed our table for even waters . We received a basket of bread but no butter or plates to enjoy it with. Our server was not very attentive or helpful. Very distracted with other tables. We informed staff we were there for a birthday and did not get to celebrate as our food arrived too late before we had to head out to the show. Food was delicious. Too much too eat. Would not recommend the calamari or chicken Marsala. Ceasear salad amazing as was Carbonara. Really wish we could have enjoyed the experience more. But service just was not good.
Disappointing
Disappointing. On arrival sent straight to table.Server polite but advised each dish would serve a minimum of 3 people. So could not explore any real variety … large degree of compromise for all 9 of us. Calamari starter was excellent .2 dishes and one drink forgotten. Had to remind. Was good ambiance but expensive for what it was- sadly
The "In Place" to go in Times Square
Everyone wants to go here to eat when in Times Square. You had better make a reservation or you will never get in. There is a long wait time even with reservations and the place to wait is very crowded and be prepared to stand. Once at the table the service is excellent and the menu varied. The food is good but not the best Italian food. Still a good value for your money and enjoyable experience.
Big portions, busy restaurant for sure.
Food was good but I didn't know it was big portions
Great Italian restaurant
Excellent dining experience. The meal is done family style. The serving size was huge and feed all four of us. Food quality was excellent and the prices were extremely reasonable.
Amazing Italian Restaurant 👍
Huge restaurant with amazing and cool staffs.. Make a reservation if you want to not wait for very long time. Food serving sizes were huge.. or should i say gigantic.. for me it is good for 4 to 5 pax.. food was really good.. want serving time was not so long.. highly recommend 👍👍👍
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Carmine's New York
Booked 2 times by Carmine's New York customers.
Ranked #18 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Carmine's New York customers.
Ranked #4 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Carmine's New York customers.
Ranked #186 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Carmine's New York customers.
Great Service - amazing dinner!!
Read about the site in NYT and bought a reservation at Mother Wolf in LA 2 days later. Worked great and the food was amazing!!!
Worked perfectly!
Got the reservation (that I couldn't get anywhere else) and was able to entertain a group of friends at the infamous Bern's Steakhouse.
Got into Nobu Malibu
Wonderful! My parents are visiting and we have wanted to go to Nobu Malibu for years. I tried getting a reservation myself but it was next to impossible. So glad I was able to buy a reservation on appointment trader for a decent price!
Very easy
Was very hesitant going into this experience but am glad to say that it worked out very well ! will definitely use appointment trader in the future
Fabulous Lunch
I was veeeeeerry skeptical that this would work, particularly at a restaurant as hard to get into as Nobu Malibu, and it was perfect! We had lunch outside on the patio and it was fabulous!
Great reviewer team
Just wanted to take a second to shout out the reviewer team. Even though they probably review hundreds of listings and bids a day, they still take the time to leave great comments and respond relatively quickly. Thanks!
Incredible
I got a reservation to Don Angie, which I've been trying to book for weeks! I am very happy with this service.
Best platform out there!
Super simple, easy, and fast to secure reservations for hard-to-get restaurants and locations!
This app is life changing
This app has opened my world up to so many wonderful new experiences I would never have the chance to have without access to this awesome app! 10/10!
Worked perfectly
Was a little nervous at first but was pleased to see that the booking went through flawlessly.
Highly recommended.
Success on Short Notice
Was able to snag an indoor table at Don Angie through an absolutely seamless worry-free process.
Worked perfectly, thank you!
This is a crazy holiday season in NYC and I was very pleasantly surprised to see that AppointmentTrader works! Will be using again!
Worked flawlessly!
Worked so well! I was a bit nervous, but everything went very smoothly. purchased the reservation, and got into the restaurant seamlessly.
Love this app!
So glad I came across this app :)
Quick table in Miami
I didn’t have my hopes high as it was a party of 4. In 24 hours I had a carbone reservation available! I was very happy as my family really wanted to come here
Prime time, great meal
So easy and had a prime time which I can never seem to get on normal res apps. So worth it
Got impossible NYC res
instead of waiting weeks I got my 4 charles reservation instantly
Worked perfectly to get into Carbone. So delighted
perfect
Worked well, got me into a restaurant with no availability
I was skeptical, and I still don't really know how they managed to find this hard-to-find reservation, but it was a win-win from my point of view, and I'll use this service again.
Last minute reservation for Delilah Las Vegas
Got a last minute reservation, dinner for 2 at Delilah Las Vegas: super impressed! The process was simple, transaction seamless. We had an amazing time! Couldn’t be happier! 😍
It works!
Ok at this point I've attended a reservation purchased on AT by a friend and sold a reservation personally. Both worked pretty smoothly, nothing sketchy about it. A few areas for improvement including a way to more directly communicate between buyers and sellers, but the app always seems to be in development. AT customer support is really(!) responsive and helpful too if you have questions!
Money transfer
As a seller, I like the fact i have the ability now to transfer money out of my AT account and into a bank account. Makes getting the money much easier then the process before.
Love this app
Got to go to places otherwise unreachable
Easy Access
Very easy to get into one of the hardest restaurants to reserve in New York.
Whose name will my reservation be under when I arrive at the venue?
It can be under your name or a name you choose! Some reservation offers already include the AppointmentTrader Transfer Service which will transfer the reservation in to your name. If its not included you can add it on after buying the reservation for a small fee. One thing on that though: As many reservations become available at last minute, taking a reservation in someone else name is quick and great for privacy. Most reservations on AT are listed with a virtual phone number, so all you need to do is present the phone number at the hostess stand and you are good to go!
Payouts Blocked Because of Sell Through Rate
Does anyone know how AT plans to handle cases where a seller is quitting the platform but has a sell through rate <25%? The error message I got said to fill more bids or find other ways to increase the rate.
Is AT really going to block sellers from withdrawing their money? Especially revenue made before the sell through rate was introduced??
Tune into NBC News - Top Story Tonight 7:40p ET
Let’s go. Get more people placing bids!
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits?
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
Appointment
Transferring reservations is not supported in AT. Why not just use the name in the AT screenshot?
Buyers interested in Bern's Steakhouse: PLEASE READ
Same goes for 4 Charles and I Sodi
Prepaid Reservation Fee
Agreed. Ultimately not addressing this month after month is clearly resulting in a drop in certain venue’s rankings & sales.
Congrats on 3 mil
🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🧨🧨🧨 now on to 30 mill!
Need to cancel a bid, not getting a response… how do I do it?
Click on "Take off the Market Option" in your portfolio
Working on your bid?
Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.
Process after bid is accepted.
Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from?
Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.
What happens if my bid expires unanswered?
Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.
Carmine's New York User Reviews & Question Forums
Carmine's New York Reviews |
Authentic Reviews from AppointmentTrader Users
By 🔥 @LovelyField77 (11/05/2023 11:22 am)
Carmine's New York Yelp Reviews |
Latest Reviews On Yelp
By 👻 @Michelle S. (07/24/2024 3:00 am)
Carmine's New York Tripadvisor Reviews |
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
By 👻 @Jay Ortiz (07/22/2024 3:00 am)
AppointmentTrader Platform Reviews |
Reviews from real people using AT!
By 👻 @ConfirmableFace16 (08/01/2024 9:48 pm)
Restaurant Transfers FAQ |
Questions around how AppointmentTrader works for Restaurant Reservations
By 🦚🇫🇷 @ChoiceBird42 (04/15/2024 11:46 am)
AppointmentTrader FAQ |
Questions and Answers around the platform.
By 👻 @AuthoritativeWay35 (08/01/2024 7:57 pm)