AppointmentTrader FAQ - Cosimo's Newburgh - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Cosimo's Newburgh for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Cosimo's Newburgh from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Cosimo's Newburgh Reviews from The Last Year
This place is awesome!! Food is delicious, the staff were
This place is awesome!! Food is delicious, the staff were all very nice and eager to please. We came in with a reservation an hour before they closed and we were also a large group plus they were very busy otherwise but they still brought our food promptly and kept checking in to see if we needed anything.
my family was in a predicament on Sunday 3/17/24.
we had a reservation at Fusion on Union for 14 people for my granddaughters baptism luncheon. when we arrived they LIED and said we canceled it. I pointed out how they crossed out my reservation in their book. The manager refused to take any accountability or even offer any apology. Incompetent and rude! They took a reservation for a larger party and cancelled ours Manager didn't care that we were all there. They made no effort at all. We made a call to Cosimos and explained our situation they were so sorry we went through that and told to come right over. They bent over backwards to accommodate our large party. Within minutes we were pleasantly seated. everyone was wonderful at the establishment. their food, as always, was excellent. I just want to thank all that made, what would have been a disastrous issue, a great addition to our very special day. If you're looking for great food, reasonable pricing, and pleasant staff, go to Cosimos. You won't be disappointed.
Cosimo's is absolutely one of the best restaurants in
Cosimo's is absolutely one of the best restaurants in Newburgh and the surrounding Hudson Valley. The food is exceptional, the service top notch and the prices are very reasonable. The bar is gorgeous and their drink menu and wine selection is very good. The bartenders are super attentive and friendly. Overall a top pick! Highly recommend!
Great place for any special occasion.
Food is always delicious. Have been coming for years.
The manager Christina is great really attentive to everyone
The manager Christina is great really attentive to everyone having a great experience. Providing extra ordinary customer service. Food is always great
In the company of good friends and fellow Yelpers Marlene G.
and Kiddeft K. on Christmas Eve 2023, I am comforted with merriment, cheers, food, wine and finally in good times. I finally muster the strength to get out of my despondent and melancholy wracked with grief disposition and managed to catch a intercity bus from NYC to Hudson Valley. My travels takes me for an Italian lunch in Newburgh, NY with a party of seven which I was utterly disappointed with the food and mostly the excessive poor customer service. With optimism and faint hope, I hoped for good quality food or at least good customer service for the deficiency, but our waitress was inattentive who took her sweet time returning to our table for food orders and including bill payment pick-up. Our waitress appeared full of conviction, disconnected with reality and unable to service our table with clarity for situational awareness. It was not entirely busy with a full house of patrons during lunch hour. One friend and fellow Yelper, Kiddeft K.'s, soup was very oily greasy. One of my party member's pizza contained a strand of long blond hair which was sent back while the rest of us nearly finished our meals when his new pizza arrived. This is would never happen in NYC as it is a direct violation of NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene's sanitary health and food safety protocols. This strand of human hair embedded in food is a direct depiction of the cook or Sous chef who has long blonde hair and does not wear hair nets, nor gloves as required when handling food. We were not properly compensated either with a small percentage discount from the bill nor offered a lagniappe as one free dessert for the mishap hair in the pizza. No, I would not return. I am glad to remove Cosimo's On Union from my Yelp bookmark. All in all as a consequence, my gratuity was 15%. My lunch meal consists of: Herb baked shrimp $27.00 Jumbo shrimp, garlic & herb bread crumbs, rice, sauteed baby kale. I did not like the rice as it appears mushroom or black rice which was included. How about yellow rice cooked with salted butter with shrimp and kale vegetables as a substitute? The green kale vegetable was crunchy, but the breaded shrimp was refreshing taste than deep-fried breaded. The shrimp was peeled and deveined, but not harden to taste like rubber as deep-fried or batter fried. It was a good consistency. Melini Chianti $10.00 (glass) This is one of my predilection choice for red wine. It is light-bodied, bright ruby red in color with a nose of raspberry, blackberry and a touch of violet aroma. I actually tasted the blackberry. The finish was very subtle.
Nice place to have a good Italian meal.
Service is good too. My favorite is their pasta a la vodka.
I have never had a bad experience at this restaurant.
Food is consistently good, and service is always excellent. It's a friendly and fun atmosphere. I do not, as a rule - take the reviews for restaurants or business establishments under consideration before trying them out. I prefer to explore and experience for myself, before making a firm judgement. This stems from the idea that it may be an off night for a "server" or "chef"... So I like to give it a chance a few times, and then base my experience from that. When I read reviews that refer to staff members as "brain dead" or inattentive; and food as "greasy" by people who claim to be "fellow Yelpers" .. ( what does that really mean?) I have to laugh...and wonder about that person's attitude and disposition. Grain of salt time... Therefore, having dined many times at Cosimos's on Union, and enjoyed the service, staff and dining fare- I can say without hesitation that it is a truly wonderful restaurant with wonderful service. I highly recommend it. Especially, Becca - she is a delightful server.
We've frequented all of the Cosimo's in Orange County and
We've frequented all of the Cosimo's in Orange County and this location "used to be our favorite til this visit. We came here with friends and fellow yelper Tina Chan who came up to visit from NYC. It was an embarrassment for us for recommending this place. Our waitress was not attentive at all and pretty much brain dead, the food didn't come out all at once and one of our guest ordered a pizza that came with unfortunately a long blond hair. When we told the waitress about it they apologized and made a new pie that didn't get to the table til everyone else was done. We expected to either have it reduced as a courtesy for the inconvenience or even comped, but instead were ignored. My hubby's soup was also greasy and definitely not pasta fagioli. We'll never be back!
Our party of 3 had very good food, but the Honey Ginger
Our party of 3 had very good food, but the Honey Ginger salad that I got to take home had no wonton noodles on it! Otherwise, we all enjoyed what we ordered. My daughter said that her salmon with broccoli rabe was the best she'd ever had. Our waitress was excellent, so I hope this wasn't her fault. The only other thing that ruined our experience was the 4 people at the table next to us. One girl was constantly hacking a horrible cough and they were so darned LOUD that you couldn't hear any of our conversation. I guess we should have asked to be moved. Cosimos is a family favorite, so I hope to eat there again soon. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------8/9/2014 UPDATE TO MY REVIEW: The owner contacted me with a nice personal message about speaking to her employees regarding the uncalled for bad service. Since this incident was an isolated one based on all of the times we've dined there and not the owner's fault, I've given a higher rating and will also go back because their cuisine is usually excellent and their service has in the past been on par. Will update about my next experience. Thanks for your professionalism, Chrissy! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cosimos in Newburgh has been a favorite of my family for many years. We've had big parties there and I've even sidetracked to stop in for my favorite dish to take out: Chicken Chinois Salad. Today, Mom and I made a special trip over to the restaurant for a late lunch. We both said that we will never go back there again. Mom's Pizza Margarita was very good, but my Chinois salad was not like it used to be. It had cheap Chinese noodles on it instead of the crisp rice noodles and the dressing was not as tasty as it once was years ago. I was given a hefty portion of salad, though. The service was the clincher for me. I guess 2 little old ladies who came for just a pizza and salad weren't deemed worthy to wait on. The waitress only came once to see if we "needed anything" and asked as she breezed by our table. If we did need something, I would have had to chase her down to get it. Mom ate half the pizza and took the rest home. It was placed in a pizza box. However, the waitress came to the table with a covered container and just said to me "Your extra dressing is in here." I was in shock as I've never had to shovel my leftovers (with my fork and HAND!) into a container even in a diner!
if you want waste your money!!!
ordered eggplant parm it was 30% eggplant 70% pasta. also ordered garlic bread it was burata something or other but was approximately 7 inches long very little taste and 15 dollars. cosimos has turned into a joke!!!!!
Great food, and Tatiana the Terrific
Great food and superior service from Tatiana the Terrific! Highly recommend the restaurant, the staff, and most particularly Tatiana for her warmth, professionalism, and grace.
Superior Staff Member
We've visited here several times in the past. In general we prefer their Poughkeepsie location. On this day we stopped by for a quick lunch and ordered a lunch pizza and drinks. Both were fine. The reason for the 5 stars is that our server was excellent. She was the type of friendly, efficient and knowledgeable employee who anticipates needs and remembers everyone. If I had not lost my receipt I'd name her but I'll certainly post again if I find it. It was a pleasure being there.
Two visits this summer, both 10/10!
Excellent! Two visits this summer while visiting West Point. Did not disappoint either time. Great staff and excellent meals! Really enjoyed all of our meals from pizza and flatbreads to salads and pasta. Will definitely visit again when in the area. Great for couples, families, and business gatherings.
Will not Return
Ordered Calamari Appetizer. Looked like they were trying to empty kitchen. Portion was very large had very few calamari rings but lots of legs and very dry. The seafood Fra diavolo was also very large and also looked like a kitchen emptier. Everything was tasteless and really uneatable. Will avoid this place in Future.
Great first visit!
This was our first time here. We were driving from NYC to Albany. The chicken park was exceptional. Everyone enjoyed their meals. Our server, Andrew, was excellent!
Skip Newburgh and go to the Pok location
The Poughkeepsie Cosimos is usually Very Good to Excellent but we weren’t happy with Newburgh. We got the half pizza/salad lunch option. In Pok you can get half of any pizza that u want but in Newburgh u can only get Margarita. Plus the Cesar salad was swimming in dressing making it almost inedible. Won’t go back to the Newburgh location!
Only one Disappointment
We have been visiting Cosimo’s in Newburgh, Middletown and Central Valley for years (originally the Newburgh site). My visits have been both with family and for business, with co-workers and business acquaintances. I have always enjoyed the variety on the menu and my favorite became the Mediterranean salad. Unfortunately this, and several other favorites are no longer on the menu. In fact, the menu is much trimmed down from years past. This was also observed by a business friend who has also gone there for years. Don’t get me wrong, this latest dinner was wonderful, all four of our family had a great time. I am, however, disappointed that the owners have decided to make the overall enjoyment options so much less.
Newburgh's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Cosimo's Newburgh
AppointmentTrader FAQ
Questions and Answers around the platform.
53,254 People following
928 Questions
627 Answers |
Ask a question about AT |
Tune into NBC News - Top Story Tonight 7:40p ET |
Let’s go. Get more people placing bids!
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits? |
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
Appointment |
Transferring reservations is not supported in AT. Why not just use the name in the AT screenshot?
Buyers interested in Bern's Steakhouse: PLEASE READ |
Same goes for 4 Charles and I Sodi
Prepaid Reservation Fee |
Agreed. Ultimately not addressing this month after month is clearly resulting in a drop in certain venue’s rankings & sales.
Congrats on 3 mil |
🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🧨🧨🧨 now on to 30 mill!
Need to cancel a bid, not getting a response… how do I do it? |
Click on "Take off the Market Option" in your portfolio
Working on your bid? |
Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.
Process after bid is accepted. |
Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from? |
Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.
What happens if my bid expires unanswered? |
Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.
Newbie sellers— how fast do your reservations sell?
I have some reservations coming up tomorrow that have gotten lots of views but haven’t sold yet. I haven’t made a sale yet since I just joined this week. I keep lowering the price, but am worried they won’t sell. How long did it take you to sell your first reservations? And did you have success being reimbursed by AT for no-show or cancellation fees? Just looking for a little reassurance. Thanks!
Give the best answerHow do I sell my when my related reservation’s restaurant does not exist on AT?
How do I sell my when my related reservation’s restaurant does not exist on AT? Its listed as a hotel, but it also has a restaurant under the same name ‘Chiltern Firehouse’ in London
Give the best answerPayment taken , reservation not received
I just bought a reservation, the money was taken from my Apple Cash. The reservation however does not show up in my portfolio
Give the best answeremail address for my acc
I left my employer and need to change my email address for my account. How do I do this?
Give the best answerSeller with the Polo Bar reservation on 5/17 for 4 people
I am interested if you are willing to negotiate. Post on my wall if/when you see this.
Give the best answerZ’Z Club
I have reservations!
Give the best answerMoney in trader points disappeared
Hi everyone- I have made a couple of sales now and I am extremely disappointed.
I had money to transfer over that became available in my "traderpoints" section that has disappeared completely. its gone.
has this happened to anyone?
also- when I click the money pending, im unable to click my pending deposit account
so upsetting
How to list a Nobu Malibu reservation
Hi, I have a reservation to Nobu Malibu, but since they don't do text or e-mail confirmations I haven't been able to get my reservation posted. I have posted a screen shot of the phone conversation on the listing, but it keeps getting rejected. If anyone has an idea how I can get it approved that would be much appreciated, thanks!
Give the best answerHolding a bid
What does it mean to hold a bid? and how do you do that?
Give the best answerNeed to change the date but its being worked on
How do I modify?! I am no longer traveljng that day but since the reservations opened up today someone grabbed it and is working on it for a month from now and i cant figure out how to and if i can modify the date!
Give the best answerReservation Name
Ok - Newbie question here - I just purchased a reservation as a gift. How do I know/change the name on the reservation?
Give the best answerRome
Can anyone help with a reservation for Aroma (vis a vis from the Colosseum) in Rome?
6 PAX 21.5 19-20:00
Thank you!
Can’t wait to last minute?!
How do you set a timeline for getting your bid accepted? I can’t wait till the actual time I want to go. I want to know at least eight hours ahead of time. How do you do that?
Give the best answerHow do I choose the restaurants to make a reservation for?
I can’t find restaurants with high performance or like what’s the most popular restaurant or what is in short supply? Any advice?
Give the best answerConcierge change fulfillment time
I posted a request for a reservation this Thursday between 6:30 and 8 pm and initially the potential seller said it would be fulfilled by today. Now they changed it that they will only fulfill it by 5pm that same day. Basically I would have an hour and a half to get to the restaurant. Is this allowed?
Give the best answer@bravehand53
Hi. Is today Cote reservation for 4people at 8:00pm - 9:00pm for indoors or outdoors?
Give the best answer2 Ppl 5pm san Sabino res
Anyone want?
Give the best answerApp
This app is a catfish and overrun by people programming “bots” and algorithms. It makes it frustrating for someone not well versed in this to have any movement. I thought this would be a fun side hustle, but unfortunately it’s become like any other “side hustle”. Don’t waste your time with this crap. Not a question, just a suggestion. Also don’t pay these fake “gurus” hundreds of dollars to teach you. Might as well sign up for a software class. 😕
Give the best answerMy reservation review keeps getting rejected
I have a reservation for Kasama Chicago on Mother’s Day at 7:30 pm to sell but it keeps getting rejected
Give the best answermore then 15 submissions at the same time
can i get more then 15 submissions at the same time and how do i make this happen
Give the best answerWrong resy
I bought a resy for Tatiana By Kwami and when i unlocked seller lied it was for a different restaurant
Give the best answerSold reservation
What do I do with the reservation after I sell it? Do I need to notify the restaurant?
Give the best answerPaid $75 for name change that didn’t happen and cannot get anyone to reply
I paid $75 for a name change for a reservation. I bought last week that name change did not happen when I got to the restaurant they did not have my name. Luckily they took me anyway because I had the name on the reservation. AppointmentTrader owes me $75 and I can’t get anyone to reply, how do I claim my $75
Give the best answerPostpaid?
One of the reservations I put up for sale is notated “postpaid” whereas none of my others make any mention. What gives??
Give the best answer