New York New York Pizza Tampa Yelp Reviews - New York New York Pizza Tampa - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at New York New York Pizza Tampa for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at New York New York Pizza Tampa from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Tampa's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of New York New York Pizza Tampa
New York New York Pizza Tampa Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
40 Reviews
0 Replys |
First time - heard about it.
Stopped by for lunch and had a slice of pepperoni and the wife had florentine...both were very good! Large slices - inexpensive! Made for a perfect lunch. Will be a regular going forward! Service was excellent (friendly!) as well. Beautiful day to eat outside in their street tables.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing pizza! Been going for YEARS when I used to party
Amazing pizza! Been going for YEARS when I used to party down in Ybor. Now we order at work so I can share the goodness! Delivery is ALWAYS on time if not early, pizza is hot and the driver is always super nice! A++
Be the first to ReplyNew York New York pizza is so good.
The service is quick and efficient. Love the ambiance of the place !
Be the first to ReplyGreat pizza great meatballs.
Service is really good. Will come back here for my pizza fix again.
Be the first to ReplyOrdered Lg pizza with onions, mushrooms, and banana peppers.
There was "maybe" 1 piece of each topping per slice. The crust was like cardboard, and barely any cheese. I lived in NYC for 3 years, and there is nothing New York style about their pies. The worst I've had since moving here.
Be the first to ReplyThis restaurant was delicious! Our waitress was very
This restaurant was delicious! Our waitress was very courteous and was very attentive.
Be the first to ReplyPizza is definitely authentic! The staff is absolutely
Pizza is definitely authentic! The staff is absolutely incredible! A must try if you are in Ybor.
Be the first to ReplyWalked in (not out) .
Ordered one slice. Sober. Saw my slice make on the counter. Waited 10more minutes for the nice one to say that was my pizza. Stared eating my pizza for the terrible one to yell at me and state I wasted a pizza box. Advice: know who the clientele is and what they ordered before making crazy accusations. She clearly needs a break.
Be the first to ReplyIf you are in the Tampa area do yourself a huge favor and
If you are in the Tampa area do yourself a huge favor and get pizza from here. You will not be disappointed!! Authentic NYC pizza place with a great vibe. Workers are super.
Be the first to ReplyActually this pizza is quite good.
Just make sure you order a fresh pie. Not the slices that are sitting there.
Be the first to Replyall the workers are dicks.
never a good experience. also make sure you know the right prices because they love charging people double the price at night smh
Be the first to ReplyI guess when it's 1 AM and you've been out in Ybor and need
I guess when it's 1 AM and you've been out in Ybor and need a slice this will do in that pinch, but otherwise it's a disappointing and underwhelming pie. Looks good but super dry, little flavor. Not worth the money.
Be the first to ReplyAbsolute scumbags .
I ordered 1 large pizza and they charged me for 3 lol All crooks becareful especially at night they'll double charge you
Be the first to ReplyJust look at the pizza.
..Maybe they had an intern? Maybe the cook had a bad day at home? Maybe the employees don't get paid enough? Did everyone call in sick? Pepperoni pizza can't be that hard... Strange burnt pieces sprinkled, pepperoni on one side, grease twinkling and it's not even cut all the way. I ordered it for my step kids and now I'm embarrassed. They are not picky at all and even they had something to say about it. Oh well. Bad day for the cook I guess...at least it's food. Definitely not ordering from here again.
Be the first to ReplyOrdered through A abet Eats and the food was cold.
Burnt bottom so it was hot at one point. Upon delivery pizza and wings were cold
Be the first to ReplyHave been ordering from the Temple Terrace location since
Have been ordering from the Temple Terrace location since they opened. I believe the ownership/team is different, has to be. What once was a good pizza is now either delivered cold or like tonights the underside of the crust was undercooked and mushy. As a New Yorker if the crust does not crack do not call yourself a New York pizza. Never again.
Be the first to ReplyWe ordered the medium pepperoni and added jalapeรฑos.
When it arrived it only had jalapeรฑos no pepperoni. We tried calling and no one answered.
Be the first to Replywhat a dump so nasty an service was really rude !!
what a dump so nasty an service was really rude !! there's better an nicer pizza places in Ybor who respect you business Don't try it move on
Be the first to ReplyPretty good pizza place for a quick slice.
Typical NY style and its tasty and quick!
Be the first to ReplyYou cant come to ybor city and not stop at New York New
You cant come to ybor city and not stop at New York New York pizza it's an absolute must ! It's ither the start of a great night or it's definitely the best part after ending a long night on the way to the car like I don't know what I would do if nyny wasn't conveniently located where it's located it's been a savior for me on multiple occasions love place check them out ! And be safe partying down in ybor !
Be the first to ReplyWas staying in the area and found this place.
Came and ate here 3 times. Everything was delicious. Highly recommended!
Be the first to ReplyJust for the warm welcome you got me and " Hello" Now let's
Just for the warm welcome you got me and " Hello" Now let's try this Pizza. Should beside the fly that was trying to eat my slice. The pizza was mediocre it came out hot nice presentation didn't have any flavor no sauce . Although I'm sure with a couple of beers it would taste amazing. The meatballs reminded me of my mother's meatballs, I wasn't a fan of my mother's meatballs. But again the service was so warm .
Be the first to ReplyWhen down visiting one of the distilleries we wanted some
When down visiting one of the distilleries we wanted some good pizza... And this place did not disappoint!!!!!From the inside you the smell of pizza consumes the room. The restaurant itself is clean, nothing fancy and I like that. The staff is super friendly and very helpful. We ordered several apps, but the winner in this category was the garlic knots. Y. U. M. Buttery garlic nuggets sent down from above. For the pizza, again. Yum. The cheese is just salty enough, the sauce gives it just the flavor you are looking for and the dough... Solid yet foldable and the flavor meshes with the toppings and sauce to make just a darn good slice. Highly recommend this place!!!!
Be the first to ReplyNot anything crazy, but $6 for a slice of dry crust.
It's nice you can order from a window since I had my dog with me. Took about a minute to get a slice. The pizza is definitely greasy, I had to wipe my napkin with it. The cheese was really good on it.
Be the first to ReplyBomb pizza anyone that knows a good slice shoukd go here if
Bomb pizza anyone that knows a good slice shoukd go here if there lookin for a good pie .
Be the first to Reply